SUFFERING THE TRUTH
By Bernard W. Bail, M.D.
PATIENT
HISTORY
The patient is a young woman who I have written about in a prior essay “The More Things Change, The More They Stay The Same”. She has a younger brother and sister. She has learned a great deal about her parents who psychologically have never been available to her.
INTRODUCTION
The
prelude to the dreams below is as follows. The patient had gone out with some
friends to a Korean restaurant. Later she became very ill with a severe
gastro-intestinal upset. This followed on through the night to the morning.
Being protective of me, she called in for her session not knowing for sure
whether it was the bad food or the beginning of a viral infection. In the
meantime she contacted several of her friends, none of whom had any difficulty
with the food.
She
related her dream to me regarding the man and woman who are angry with her and
fighting with her and, as she says, whatever the problem is they think it is
"all my fault". In addition she tells me about her sister who, it
has been discovered, has an epigenetic disorder; a gene that should be turned
on has been turned off.
The
sister had been having many physical problems which could not really be
identified. This seems to be a central discovery in helping her to get on a
path to recovery.
In
my essay, The Mother's Signature, I wrote that the mother's imprint and
unconscious process was fateful for the life of the baby. I wrote that our
destiny is determined by this, the course of our lives, the ups and downs and eventually
even the manner in which we will die. Professor Haig of Harvard in 2006
published his research, which proclaimed mothers can turn the babies genes off
or on. Others in the field confirmed his finding. Being a scientist he was
recording a fact calling it "unconscious". I do not, however, expect
him to be acquainted with the term the unconscious and its ramifications which
is really the province of the psychoanalyst. This finding confirmed my theory,
which I set forward in my essay. I have since elaborated this theory in many
essays on my website.
The
session unfolded and it did not miss the patient's awareness that her GI upset
could have an emotional origin. She told me she had told their mother of the
source of this turned off gene was the mother herself. The mother was terribly
upset despite the patient saying, "You did not know this was happening.
It was not conscious".
In
view of this information I found it interesting that the dream revealed an
early part of her life in which she was constantly portrayed as the
"problem". She disturbed the equanimity of the family. However, in
time the psychoanalysis sorted out the truth, that she was constantly whistle
blowing the parents who obviously did not like this or like her for doing this.
In time, as she learned there was a more peaceful solution to the family
problem and these accusations stopped.
So
it is no wonder that in the dream she is in the middle of the man and the woman
(her parents) and being blamed as if the genetic problem of her sister was her
fault. It was my feeling that the mother did not or could not accept the
information and projected it back into the patient, which is why she became
ill. It must have been a very violent projection.
What
is left to ponder is that the patient expects another disaster, invoking the
Gulf Oil spill, and no one can estimate how great the damage will be.
SESSION May 31, 2010
Patient: I had to call today because I really feel like I
couldn’t drive. I had dinner last night with some friends. We all basically
ate the same thing because it was served family style. I am not sure whether
it was food poisoning from the food I ate or whether there is an emotional
cause. I haven’t heard that anyone else got sick.
Dr.
B: What are you doing for it?
Patient:
I haven’t really done anything yet. I am drinking some soda. I have some
medication I can take if it gets worse, but right now I am just waiting to see
if it passes.
I
had a dream early this morning.
DREAM
In the dream I was in a hotel in New Orleans and I was
fighting with a man and a woman and they are angry with me and I just want the
fighting to stop. I get the idea that they think that it is all my fault. I
am a bad friend and they are angry. I just want the fighting to stop.
Patient:
I have been concerned about my sister who has had some strange health
complaints over the last few years and has seen many doctors who have treated
many symptoms, but the overall feeling that she is not quite right continues.
She finally saw an endocrinologist who made a discovery about one of her
underlying problems. He found that she has an epigenetic disorder so a gene
that should be turned on and helping her to clear toxins from her body is
actually off.
Over the weekend I told my mother that the epigenetic
disorders seem to actually stem from the mother’s unconscious turning the gene
off before birth. I felt like it was difficult to tell my mother that part of
the information but at the time she appeared to understand it and was not defensive
about it. I did try to stress that what went on in my sister’s body before
birth was the result of unconscious actions and not her conscious intent. I am
still worried about my sister though. I just want everything to be OK for her.
I
have been to New Orleans but currently my mind goes to the oil spill. It seems
that the area is now going to be hit with another devastating injury. I don’t
recognize the hotel that I am in, although it was somewhat nice. It had a
sort of formal, antique feeling to it. There was wallpaper and I was sitting
in the corner of a room that might have led to a hallway. I could not really
remember what the man and woman looked like. I think that he was tall with
brown hair and glasses and I am less sure about the woman. I just knew that
they felt that I had done something wrong or something that upset them and they
were now fighting with me about it.
Dr.
B: Don’t you remember that your parents were often upset with you for many
years?
Patient:
Right. I know. I was always a problem when I pointed out things in the family
I thought weren’t right.
Dr.
B: I think you got sick because you told your mother about the epigenetic
disorder and then took in your mother’s guilt about harm done to your sister.
SESSION June 1, 2010
Patient: The next day I was able to go into the office.
I am feeling much better, although not completely well. I had a dream this
morning.
DREAM
I am in an apartment and I had been out with my sister
and I had parked my car on the street. I can’t remember where I parked my
car. I go to the window to look out and I get distracted by something going on
in between the building I am in and the one across from me. The buildings face
each other and there is a street in the middle. Someone is putting up some
kind of set for a movie. It is big and made of metal and I am watching them
put it together and then a bunch of five year olds come marching through the
apartment. I wake up before I find my car so I am not sure if I can find it or
not.
Patient: I think the
buildings are sort of like a New York street setting. It is a four or five
story building. I am not sure whether it is my apartment or someone else’s. I
know that I had been somewhere with my sister, maybe to lunch, and we had come home.
I wasn’t sure whether I drove home and parked the car somewhere or whether I
ended up leaving the car at the restaurant. I think the restaurant was close
enough that we could have walked home. I looked out of the window and I
couldn’t really see if I had parked the car on one of the streets. I was
distracted by the set that someone was building. I thought it was a movie set.
It was tall and black and made of metal. I am not sure exactly what it was
going to be. Then the kids came in. I think they were about five years old.
There were quite a few of them and there didn’t seem to be any parents. I felt
like I needed to take care of them or at least make sure that they were OK.
Dr. B: I think that this
dream shows that you cannot find your personality, symbolized by your car,
because you were occupied with being a mother to your sister. She is the group
of little children. Additionally, it shows that your sister is not able to
really concentrate because there is too much chaos in her mind adding to the
reasons that you are concerned about her.
COMMENTARY
I put forward this small
essay for two reasons. First it confirms the fact that a mother's unconscious
can turn off or on genes in the child she is bearing. In this case a gene was
turned off. This theory was proposed in my essay The Mother's
Signature and confirmed scientifically by Dr.
David Haig at Harvard (see my essay The Silent Struggle) and a corollary group in Japan. Second it revealed
the capacity or lack of capacity of a person receiving an unwelcome truth, that
is the mother. She acknowledges consciously her terrible feelings about this
information. Yet unconsciously she rejects this idea and projects it back to
her daughter who became very ill with nausea and vomiting. In a way the
daughter is also identified with the mother by physically vomiting out this
idea. The dream confirms the patient has always been a "mother" to
her sister and reveals the sister's emotional age...she is just a child.
Copyright © Bernard
W. Bail, M.D.
August
2010 |