Venice Beach
by Bernard W. Bail, M.D.
Bikers, skaters, walkers and
runners love the beach from Rose Avenue
north. The rest of us are drawn to
honky-tonk, tinsel, glittering baubles, beach cafe dining, crowd the boardwalk
listening to music, fingering the huge amount of goods of infinite variety-
beads, rings, semi-precious stones, pictures, paintings, straw hats, Indian
henna painting, tarot card and palm readers sitting and waiting for customers.
Us! Everything seems to be affordable. To me, best of all, would be looking
into the future.
I have written elsewhere that
fortune tellers have always been with us in every society, in all times known
to man, even in times forgotten by us. Why should this be so?
I have a theory. Being made
in the image of God I can put myself in the mind of God. I can imagine God
saying to himself, "These folks, these creatures I have made after some
false starts, when they settle down enough to feel a little relief from danger,
like being eaten by some voracious animal, someone is going to ask 'How does
all this happen? Who made it?'"
Man was not that smart. We
know it took a long time to get the connection between fornication and the
birth of a baby later on. I don't know how long that took. So, God reasons,
some soul with his belly full, looking around the landscape, a beautiful one
with trees, grass, flowers, blue sky and sun, night sky with stars and moon,
asks, "Who made it?"
Scientists stay away from the
question of who made the big bang or what caused it. No one knows how long
something existed before an atom was rent asunder to cause everything that
exists in the universe and in our world today with all of its trouble. Some
people want to blame God for our man-made problems. People always have, even
to killing other human beings to alleviate bad fortune and propitiate the God
(or Gods). We have not come very far in our evolution of consciousness.
Scientists feel it is
important to establish first causes and currently a group is assembled in
Switzerland at a several miles long collider where atoms are being hurled at
each other so that hopefully we may see and know first hand what happened a
long time ago; cause and effect. That seems to be the law that permeates the
universe. It seems too, though humans can see how that works in science, we
have a hard time putting that law to our affairs in daily life even though
everyday life puts our feet to that unpleasant fire.
In the main that law is
ignored, especially in the public domain. All governments behave as if THEY
were first cause, as if THEY can erase a page or tear out a page and start
anew. We know in science that is impossible.
When people, even at the
highest levels with the highest intelligence, do that we call it omnipotence.
If we see this in our practices we know that person is in for a fall for it
indicates he/she is living a life and not paying attention to reality.
Reality, however, never fails to pay attention to us. How do the governments
of the world get away with it? Obviously looking at the condition of the
world, they don't.
I think today everyone knows
how that is done, but it is more difficult since people have evolved a little
and the technology that exists gives everyone knowledge quickly. There is some
transparency, though not completely. There are still plenty of lies going
around despite the fact that lies make people sick. This is demonstrable, as
demonstrable as smoking will cause cancer or that alcohol will damage bodily
integrity. We have the adage that nothing that man makes is invulnerable to
abuse or corruption. We have not come to that state of consciousness in which
we recognize it and stay away from it as we do these days from blood letting.
We no longer believe that works although it was widely believed several hundred
years ago.
A patient was walking the
boardwalk at Venice Beach and decided to get a reading. To his surprise the
man, let us call him Jim, was accurate. My patient was quite amazed after
having his palm and the tarot cards read for him. The information was quite
accurate.
I think science would scoff
at this as not being scientific, that is not verifiable objectively. But there
can be a science of the subjective realities that inhabit all of us. The
information given to my patient made his heart beat faster as Jim, who had
never met him or knew him, began to tell him truths about himself.
I suppose we could attach
electrodes and measure the physiologic changes. These outward readings would
not accomplish the complexity of feelings, thoughts and conclusions and new
ideas that come into existence subjectively as more and more is told.
By comparison and perhaps we
should not compare the information gathered in Switzerland which may be of
great importance in unraveling the esoteric mysteries of the universe. We do
not live in that esoteric atmosphere. We do have a similarity; science and
humanity. We both live according to the laws of cause and effect. There is no
arguing that. We in the domain of everyday life are still arguing that proposition.
Scientists do not question it.
That is our end goal, all of
us, even scientists who, like us, have a private life have to come to consider
the law of cause and effect as basic to life and to survival.
To continue the story of
being like God who said, "Let me give them (us) as many clues as I can to
derive what this endeavor (life) is all about. I will give them all that
exists on earth today. I will not give them war or a religion that makes
people suffer or a paradigm that it is all right to torture or kill in my
name. All of that would be upon man's conscious. I am about one thing, peace,
quiet and love, helping the other person as all are made in my image.
Therefore all are patently divine. I see, however, they do not seem to know this
and there are individuals who feel it is in their interest to maintain a
philosophy of separation, to keep the other mentality alive. I have given them
free choice and they will enjoy the consequences that come about from their
choice."
"Indeed I sent Jesus who
said life is all about love and loving each other, for all are the same. He
said in one talk, and I know that anyone can read it in the gospel of Thomas
10,
'If
you bring forth what is in you, what you bring forward will save
you.
If you do not bring forward what is in you, what is in you will
destroy
you.'
"I gave them the first
psychoanalyst so that man might know how to do it, how to achieve this higher
state of consciousness, of evolution. So far few have followed the way. It is
the only way to overcome unconscious, early and never forgotten injuries."
"Anything less than this
will cause these events to be projected onto future generations as they have
been for many, many past generations."
In other words it is my
belief that God or nature, whatever you want to call it, does give us the
answer to help ourselves. We have ignored Jesus and other people of similar
high quality. A time must come.
It is my belief that the
unconscious and the dream, which must be interpreted correctly, has all the
answers that we want and need, and here we are making progress slowly. If we
read the symbolism of Jesus on the donkey it is as if high consciousness is
riding on a stupid, stubborn animal slowly. Man is that animal.
Two thousand years ago there
lived a man called John the Baptist. It came to him that emersion was the way
to go. He stood in the river and baptized hundreds or thousands, even Jesus,
but it fell to Jesus the way it could be done - that is cleansing oneself of
illness - talking.
It cannot be ignored that the
symbol for the unconscious is water and that analysts have to get into the
water with their patients to cleanse them of their ancient wounds.
Freud discovered the talking
cure. Its power and popularity have waned as indeed has the unconscious and
the dream that deals with it. John the Baptist achieved another mark of
progress along the path of man's evolution of consciousness.
***********************************
A CASE EXAMPLE
The patient is a man of elder
years. He was born in a Midwestern city. He has had a successful career over
many decades. Now he is old and plagued by physical problems which, luckily,
are not life threatening but exceedingly annoying and about which he complains
endlessly. He came because he knew that I, being old, would understand his
complaints, indeed his fear. How would he make the transit? He had heard
about me in some derivative way and after due diligence decided to come and
give me a chance. Could I help him with that? I thought we should try. So
this patient is not about early anxieties or about current relationships. This
work is not about his successes in life of which he has had no small measure.
Personally I felt that there were more successes coming to him. He doubts that.
He is constantly deriding me by saying that his unconscious will yield the
answer to his physical complaints. "That's OK", I thought. "It
is Ok for him to be skeptical". I can appreciate his doubts. When one is
in the grip of a physical symptom it is difficult to believe that some mental
complex, an unreal entity, has caused it.
We have all been there.
But throughout is the running
theme of being done, time to go. Not infrequently there are announcements of
colleagues dying. His philosophy about those who are envious or jealous of him
is "outlive them". He was doing that nicely. So this day he brings
this dream.
DREAM
I am in my old
neighborhood. In fact, I am in my old house. I realize that my mother is
there. I don't know how old I am. I do know I have to pee. I go to the
bathroom. My mother, though I can't see her at all, I know is on her knees
scrubbing the floor. I also know and am thinking about her wish to eat with
me. I begin to urinate and then stop out of respect for her and I go to
another bathroom. I am thinking of all the things I have to do. It seems to
be the weekend. I say to her, "I have things to do so I will be busy
during the day". She responds, though I don't see her, "I did want
to have supper with you and that will be fine."
Patient: I didn't know how
old I was in the dream but certainly at my age I know my mother would not be
alive. I am at peace with her. She was never really a problem and always a
joy especially the cheese and tomato sandwiches she would make for me to take
to school. But I don't feel well. I have discomfort in my stomach. I take my
usual pharmaceutical but it is the same story.
Dr. B: Did you eat your
usual breakfast? (I am very sympathetic to his complaints and do not mind
listening to the ever present symptoms of dyspepsia, bloating and constipation)
Patient: I am afraid to be
too bold in what I eat but I think I am too fearful of timidness in that
respect as well. I usually have to urinate once during the night but doesn't
everyone after a certain age? The fact is I have nothing to do except minister
to myself. I can't help it. I am always listening to what is happening in my
body.
Dr. B: Your medical
examinations and your doctors all say there is nothing wrong.
Patient: But I think they
have missed something. You know doctors are not too smart.
Dr. B: Me too, I guess.
Patient: Yes, you too.
Dr. B: I understand your
beliefs except they are not confirmed anywhere objectively but I want to go
over your dream because it answers a question you frequently bring up and the
issue which caused you to come here and talk with me in the first place which
is are you going to die. The dream says not yet that there is more for you to
do. Isn't that what you told your mother who happens to be the Divine Mother
or Mother Nature, as you prefer. She will have dinner with you at whatever
time you wish, whenever you are through with what you have to do. At that time
you can release everything to her.
Patient: I do have things to
do but no desire to do them. I guess all I have done accordingly to the dream
is prelude.
Dr. B: Are you enjoying
where you are?
Patient: It was fun in the
past and in part but it was also hard, very hard.
(The patient looked away
pensively. We were silent for a moment and then closed the session)
COMMENTARY
I think this session is
simple and transparent and we get a taste of the patient's depression over his
physical symptoms which foreshadow some psychological trauma in the distant
past. What is striking to me is that despite over time there were occasions
when his dreams predicted certain outcomes, accurately so. He still does not
have the ultimate conviction of the truths his unconscious continues to give
him.
It is my impression that we
have so endued the conscious mind with idolatry that it is hard to pay
attention to any information from another source, that is the unconscious. The
intellect has been glorified and the more complex ideation it puts out, the
more there is marvel to behold. It may and usually is found that this
information may be incorrect. I think this distrust of the unconscious and the
dream which weaves the truth is a projection of the distrust of the conscious
intellectual mind which has been so idealized. In the hands of a person of
intelligence and charm just about anything can be said and have the shroud of
truth. Often the shroud is all that remains. For me it is an indication of
man's fear of the unknown which puts him (all of us) in a bind. If not the
truth (!) of the intellect what else is there? When I suggested to the patient
that his unconscious contains the answer to his physical problems he laughed.
I agree it seems to be a hard stretch but working analysts know that the
stretch, however long, has its time when this truth will be revealed to the
patient. He continues to be fearful and other dreams contain bits and pieces
of material that confirm his great fear.
We have come a distance from
the boardwalk at Venice Beach with its panoply of color and excitement and people
who read other people's fortunes very accurately. The masses surge by not ever
knowing this can be done. Why should they know about the treasures of the
unconscious and the dream? The masses do not know yet that just within them - a
sleep away - lays the best fortune teller, palm reader, tarot reader and
scientific observer in the world.
April 2009
Copyright © Bernard W.
Bail, MD
|