WHY
DR. DOMBROWSKI DOESN'T HAVE A LIFE
by Bernard W. Bail, M.D. Observers
of the political scene have been confused by
the steady voting of certain
blocs in the country that constantly and happily, it
seems, vote on candidates and issues that will ultimately
adversely affect all of us. These pundits
are bewildered as rightly anyone might be at this behavior.
However, it is not so different from abused
children who are brought to court and asked whether
they wanted to go home or to a foster home. A
very high percentage say home - to the parents who
have abused them and will again.
It is not a mystery if one considers
a forceful projection of a mother’s unwanted self into the infant,
splitting his/her nascent being– a violent and
therefore hateful experience for the child (see The
Mother’s Signature, 2001, for a discussion
of the imprinting process). The child has to
split this off and deny its existence or has to advertise
its existence. These are individuals who later
seek out partners who will duplicate this infantile
experience. Later in life these people choose
to be badly treated and seem to be truculently happy
as if daring anyone to stop them from their pain. No
one can.
This knowledge is the answer to
the pundit's confusion. This
knowledge gives information about what aspect of everyday
life, that is political life, that seems obscure, confusing
and impenetrable.
A patient in his 50's has had a few marriages,
always with cruel women, who have been ringers for
his mother, a woman who would bring her children to
an older dentist in the city. This dentist did
not give anyone anesthesia nor did he numb the teeth
for any work he did. Mind you, this is in a large
city of many of hundreds of thousands of people with
very good medical and dental professionals. When
the patient would cry and tremble at the pain in fixing
his cavities, his mother shook him and scolded him. Why
was he so bad?
The description of the experience
with the dentist was his association to a dream he
had previously. In
the dream he was in Montana in a beautiful field of
grass. The sky and weather were perfect and on
a knoll was a rather ramshackle house. He immediately
thought of the dentist who had caused so much pain
and his mother who insisted that he endure it.
I will come back to the Montana
dream, for in this analytic session he was talking
about a current disturbing
dream about his wife from whom he has separated recently. In
this dream, she showed him her car that she had wrecked. (This
was true for many cars he had given her). He spoke
in the dream of his insurance costs per month, which
were astronomical. He then offered her his Hummer,
which she immediately drove and wrecked. He was
beside himself with rage and tried to kick her. She
backed away and said, "I am going to call the
police and say you threatened my life." He
knew he had gone too far and already saw the report,
the police coming, being in jail, etc. He was
convinced the police believed women without evidence. He
began to rage in the session. I stopped him because
it was an old canard. I said, "Why did you
lend her your car? Indeed, why are you even with
her knowing what kind of woman she is?" There
were so many previous dreams, all of which documented
the reality she had created for herself and for him
and all of this an astounding likeness to his unending
suffering as an infant and child and to that pained
state of infancy that he has lived essentially all
of his life. He knew of her emotional instability
and her irresponsibility and of her forays into cruelty.
He stopped and thought, "True, we have talked
about this many times.” Silence. "Why
do I have this dream now?” he asked himself. I
echoed his thought. He said, "I was thinking
of 1989 when I met my wife." I reminded
him even then she was revealing all the qualities she
paraded now. Then he said, "I have a great
feeling of nostalgia for the old days. I feel
guilty about my mother, that I was not good enough,
that I have betrayed her.” Then he recalled the
Montana dream and its associations to the dentist. I
said, "This is why you have the current dream. Your
guilt over having your life pain free is too much. Your
mother imprinted you with great pain and you eroticized
that pain as the only way to stay alive. This
is why, as you know, you are constantly wanting to
have sex with your wife but it is always to avoid the
feeling of pain. You are alive and you have accomplished
much in one area of your life, your profession. But
the rest is appallingly full of pain and chaos and,
when it has stopped being painful for awhile as it
has now, you bring back the entire picture of it and
a wish to be in chaos and pain as you were with your
wife and before with other women and before with your
mother who taught you how to have a miserable life
which you have had until now. It is as if you
are saying beneath your consciousness, 'Oh, my
God it is just too quiet, too dull. It is too
painful to be in the lap of luxury. Oh, my God. Let
me have what I know and what I have lived all my life. Let
me have my unhappiness.' That will make you
happy. He said, "When you say it like that
it sounds absolutely stupid except it's like the
way I have lived over 50 years." And there
we stopped for the day.
This man became a successful physician,
a reversal of the ill, traumatized person he was,
and in his unconscious,
all the patients were the traumatized parts of himself – all
of which he was trying to heal -- a Sisyphusian task
at best. Further analysis revealed that the women he
married represented all the worthless, self-hating
aspects of his mother – that is, his mother projected
these unbearable feelings into him. He split
off such an intolerable identity and then repeatedly
married women who embodied hatred and worthlessness.
I have translated the understanding of an individual
trauma into an understanding of a mass phenomenon because
most people have been emotionally traumatized in their
infancy and can no longer recall it or who was the
agent of this abuse - an abuse not consciously perpetrated
for the most part but which exists nonetheless and
has existed in every person, in every country, in every
culture for thousands and thousands of years.
We are burdened by these insults
to the mind. They
are old in the mass population. They are ever
with us and unconsciously impelling us to actions that
are detrimental to our lives - and curiously if one
is not in an analysis which examines minutely the fabric
of one's daily existence - one never knows when
the consequences begin to fall. Then it seems
that our luck has run out or we are cursed by God. There
is always an "or". There is hardly
ever a "let me try to think when my bad luck started." Naturally
when it comes to an initial trauma of infancy, as indicated
with Dr. D, it becomes very clear as to how exactly
the seeds for his future life were sown and there is
an inevitability to that life, unless one is
in analysis. Otherwise one can do nothing about
it since one does not know the cause. To do anything
about a disaster, one must know the cause, as for example,
if we know someone has a bacterial infection we know
what antibiotic to administer. All science is
based on knowing the origin of things so that we may
be more the master of those things, of our lives.
So to sum up, if Dr. D did not know
the origin of his illness, he was doomed to repeat
it as he has on
three prior occasions with unsuitable women. These
women were cut from the same mold as this cruel mother.
In addition, she married a man, his father, who was
hugely successful but equally and uniformly sadistic,
crude, a bore, an alcoholic, an abuser of his wife
and of his children. Knowing this, one can predict
that none of the children stood a good chance of surviving
their lives without addiction - whether alcohol
or drugs - or without violent behavior that might
get them killed or maimed. This prediction would
turn out to be true.
An important element in this equation
is the capacity to forget. Sometimes to forget might be fatal
to us. If we do not remember, we tend to repeat
the mistakes already a fact. If we cannot remember
what is now in our unconscious, we are destined to
repeat that trauma in someway, hardly ever the same
way. In addition to this internal dynamic, the
external world is full of forgetfulness as well as
the ways and means for us to forget.
If a country is beset by disasters
of the leader's
making, the administration of that leader will do what
it can to distract the population. It tries not
to call attention to its implication in any misstep
or in any adventure that it undertook which turned
out badly. This is not too hard to accomplish
for the ruling party in any country already has a population
used to being abused and used to forgetting the origin
of that abuse. The ruling party's interest
is always in obscuring it's responsibility when
things go badly. This is in the nature of mankind
- being that leaders themselves are so often the victim
of abusive parents. I am speaking not only of
physical abuse, for most abuse is of an emotional nature.
Our leaders are as liable as any
of us to go astray, as astray as Dr. D. Further, leaders often surround
themselves with similar companions. This intensifies
the forces which can propel bad judgments which are,
of course, rationalized. Human beings are, after
all a clever species. We can rationalize anything. The
problem is that rationalization is a lie and sooner
or later the whole thing falls apart. If there
is no one able to speak the truth, a lie may go on
longer. But ultimately it will fall apart and
then everything falls apart. One can examine
civilization to see this and verify it again and again. What
is astounding is that our current leaders do not seem
to read history. The conclusion must be that
they are so intoxicated with their power that they
truly believe they can do what they want.
We call this arrogance and/or omnipotence
and every arrogance will have a fall. It is as inevitable
as the sun rising tomorrow. This is known as
the law of karma - every action has a consequence,
and an action based on a false perception, even though
rationalized, will have a fall. It is only a
question of time. This is a law of the
universe. The Bible says it simply and eloquently, "As
ye sow, so shall ye reap". There is no escape
in this life on earth from that truth.
It is a stunning fact that no government
on earth acknowledges the existence of the unconscious
in human
affairs yet that instrument determines the fate of
every individual on earth. Because no government
acknowledges the profound effect of the unconscious,
so goes every other institution - newspapers, TV, broadcast
radio, publishing companies, etc. Yet this force
of the unconscious rules our lives and determines our
fate.
One can only see that all human
activity is the result of what I call "intellectual consciousness." It
is the result of an intellect devoid of a base, a ballast
to anchor it in psychic reality, which is the only
true reality and the one that can check what we as
a people - a government, a congress, a president -
says, plans, promulgates and acts. Our unconscious
has an answer to all of the above. It speaks
with profound knowledge because it contains the knowledge
of all mankind, of all ages of man. The unconscious
can lend credence and belief to an action or a thought
or it can say, "Do not go there because if you
do it will be at your peril."
Anyone in an analysis - even the
most devoted skeptic - will eventually concede, if
he is open minded, that
he does not rule his universe. Forces quite beyond
his consciousness do.
We have gone for so many thousands
of years without the recognition, exploration and
acceptance of the
unconscious that one can only say that the intellect
has failed in its lofty intention to bring peace to
the world, enough food and shelter to mankind, a peaceful
pursuit by each man or woman of his or her life, security,
and most of all happiness. Is it not time we
accept what we have for so long tried to exclude from
our consciousness - that we are not masters of our
destiny by intellect alone, just as we are not masters
of the natural forces that crackle like earthquakes,
that crash like the ocean, that twist and twirl around
like tornadoes and hurricanes. If we misuse the
environment, there will be a reckoning for all of mankind,
led to this folly by the rationalizations of a few
interested not in the welfare of mankind but of profit
and power for themselves.
We must explore the unconscious
as we have explored the physical universe. Admittedly, it is much
easier to explore the physical universe for it is an
external thing and easily sold by its obvious allure. In
knowing the unconscious lies man's salvation, his
destiny, his peace, his true mastery of himself, his
true realization, his true connection with all things
living and all things supposedly dead, like mountains,
with every existing entity in this world and all other
worlds we know so little about and worlds we have yet
to discover. It is in this discovery that we
will become free to know the one and only true reality.
It is in this search that we find
our moral compass. Would
any of us dare step onto an airplane or a ship without
a compass? Yet we are so prideful that we live
our lives without the instrument that the one source
has given us all - a moral compass - that lies in our
unconscious. The world has been hurling on the
wings of a single dimensionality without the sobriety
and the calming weight of unconscious knowledge.
Oh, Icarus, we have forgotten your
message and Minerva, though we named you Goddess
of Wisdom, we have yet
to enter the holiness of your temple. To a greater
or lesser degree we are all Dr. Dombrowski. Let
us pray!
October 9, 2005
(WB2005)
|